Short answer: New-hire agents need a different QA plan than tenured agents. During nesting, score more of their calls, start with a short list of must-have behaviors (verification, compliance items, accurate information and a clean close), give feedback the same day or the next, and graduate each agent to your normal QA plan when they hit written exit criteria, not when the calendar says so.

Most new hires don't fail in training. They fail in their first few weeks on the phones.

Classroom goes fine. They pass the quizzes. Then real customers show up, the system is slow, somebody's angry, and every habit they form that week is the one they keep.

That's what nesting is for. And it's where most QA programs check out. The new hire gets the same 4 or 5 scored calls a month as everybody else, usually weeks after the calls happened.

Here's how I'd run call QA for new hires instead.

What Nesting Is For

Nesting is the stretch between classroom training and full production. The agent takes live calls with extra support around them: a nesting lead, a buddy, a supervisor who's close by.

The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics notes that customer service reps usually get short-term on-the-job training, and that trainees often get guidance from an experienced worker for their first few weeks. That's nesting. The question is whether QA is part of it or just shows up afterward.

QA during nesting has a different job than QA for tenured agents:

Different job, different plan.

Step 1: Start With a Short List of Must-Haves

Don't hit a new hire with your full 30-question form on day one. They can't fix 30 things. Nobody can.

Pick the behaviors that can hurt a customer or the business if they go wrong, and score those on every reviewed call:

  1. Verification. Did the agent verify the caller the way your process requires, before sharing account details?
  2. Required disclosures and compliance items. Anything that's an auto-fail on your form.
  3. Accurate information. Did the agent give the right answer, or guess?
  4. Ownership of next steps. Did the caller leave knowing what happens next and when?
  5. Documentation. Did the notes match what actually happened on the call?

Score the rest of the form too, but coach from this list first. Once an agent is consistently clean on the must-haves, move the coaching focus to soft skills and efficiency.

Step 2: Score More Calls, Sooner

A new hire's first weeks are where the scoring volume matters most.

With 4 or 5 scored calls, you can't tell a bad call from a bad habit. We walked through why small samples swing so much in How Many QA Evaluations Do You Need Per Agent?

A simple nesting plan:

Nesting week What to score Focus
Week 1 As many calls as you can, every day Must-haves only
Week 2 Still heavy, daily Must-haves plus call flow
Week 3 Lighter, a few times a week Full form
Graduation Normal QA plan Full form

That's a layout, not a benchmark. Set the numbers based on your call volume and your QA capacity.

The point is front-loading. Heavy scoring in week one costs a lot less than three months of fixing a habit.

Step 3: Give Feedback the Same Day

A new hire who misses verification on Monday and hears about it the following Tuesday has missed it on a lot of calls in between.

Feedback during nesting should be fast and small:

Keep the tone right. New hires already feel like they're drowning. QA in nesting should feel like a spotter, not a referee. The rest of the coaching process for tenured agents still applies, just on a faster clock.

Step 4: Separate Knowledge Gaps From Skill Gaps

When a new hire misses something, figure out why before you coach it.

Look across the whole nesting class, too. If most of the class misses the same question, that's a training problem, not seven agent problems. Send it back to the training team with the calls attached.

Step 5: Write Down the Exit Criteria

"They seem ready" isn't a graduation standard. Write down what ready means before the class starts.

Exit criteria might include:

Make it clear to the agent, too. New hires do better when they know what the finish line is.

When an agent doesn't hit the criteria on time, extend nesting for that agent with a specific focus. Don't push them to the floor and hope.

Step 6: Keep Watching After Graduation

Graduation isn't the end. A lot of agents slip a few weeks after they lose the extra support.

Keep a slightly heavier QA plan for the first month or two after nesting, and watch the must-have list closely. If you see a slip, it's usually one behavior, and it's a fast fix if you catch it early.

Common New-Hire QA Mistakes

For more on scoring pitfalls in general, our 12 Common Call Center QA Mistakes post covers the usual problems.

Where OttoQA Fits

The hard part of new-hire QA is volume. Your QA team can't listen to all of a nesting class's calls and keep up with everybody else.

OttoQA scores calls against your own QA forms, so a nesting class can get heavy scoring without pulling your QA team off everyone else. No seat licenses, no IT, and setup takes about 2 weeks. There's a $1,000 one-time setup fee, and you can start with a 200 to 500 call proof of concept: we score 200 to 500 of your calls against your form.

Bottom line... the first few weeks on the phones decide what kind of agent you get. Score more, coach faster, and graduate on criteria.

FAQ

What is nesting in a call center?

Nesting is the period between classroom training and full production when new agents take live calls with extra support, like a nesting lead, a buddy or a nearby supervisor. It usually lasts a few weeks and ends when the agent meets the center's readiness criteria.

How many calls should QA score for a new hire?

More than for a tenured agent, especially in the first week or two. Score heavily and daily early on, then step down to your normal QA plan once the agent meets your exit criteria. Set exact numbers based on your call volume and QA capacity.

What should you score first on new-hire calls?

The behaviors that can hurt a customer or the business: verification, required disclosures and auto-fail items, accurate information, clear next steps and documentation. Score the full form, but coach from that short list first.

How fast should new hires get QA feedback?

The same day or the next morning. A new hire keeps repeating a missed behavior until someone tells them, so weekly feedback is too slow during nesting.

When should a new agent graduate from nesting?

When they meet written exit criteria, like no compliance misses across recent scored calls, consistent passes on must-have behaviors and sign-off from the nesting lead and QA. Not just when a set number of weeks has passed.

About the author

Tom Laird is the founder of OttoQA and CEO of Expivia, with about 30 years in contact centers. He hosts the Advice from a Call Center Geek podcast. Connect with Tom on LinkedIn.